In a curious little nook of the world, where the sunbeams danced and the shadows played, a question flitted through the air like a butterfly: “Is that a paper plane? Is that a pencil? Is it an eraser, perhaps?” But lo! A voice rang out, clear and bright, “Nay, my friends. That’s Elementary Man!”
A Curious Bet
The sun sank behind the city’s tilted rooftops, throwing long, mischievous shadows over the café table. Five friends huddled around their untouched coffees. Their eyes gleamed with the thrill of debate.
“I tell you,” said Jasper, slamming the table, “if I think hard enough, I can make that streetlight flicker!”
“Nonsense!” scoffed Tim. “I control dice rolls. I just have to will it!”
“Bah!” declared Lila. “I can predict the next song on the radio. I feel it!”
As they chattered, a sixth figure sat quietly, stirring his lemon tea in perfect circles. It was Elementary Man. He watched. He knew.
The Great Experiment Begins
The friends set their wild claims to the test.
Jasper furrowed his brows at the streetlight. Nothing.
Tim tossed dice, chanting strange syllables. “Four! Four! Four!” But the dice rolled six.
Lila pressed her ear to the café’s speakers. “The next song is definitely… ‘Blue Moon’!” The speakers hummed. A rock anthem blasted instead.
Failure after failure, they refused to yield.
“We just need…” Jasper insisted, “…better focus!”
Elementary Man sipped his tea. “Or better reasoning.”
Enter the Mysterious Stranger
Elementary Man chuckled. He wore a red scarf and a knowing smile.
“Perhaps,” he said, “you need an instructor. Do all of you believe that you have the power to control outcomes?” Jasper asked eagerly.
Jasper nodded. “More than you can imagine. Let us prove it.”
The friends leaned in. Elementary Man leaned back.
The Game of Fools
Elementary Man pulled out a coin and placed it on the table.
“Watch carefully. I shall pick up this coin and toss it in the air. Think hard. Make it land on heads.”
They focused. The coin flipped. Landed.
Tails.
“Again!” cried Lila.
Another toss. Another tails.
Elementary Man smiled. He had used a weighted coin that did not yield heads. “Let’s try other games instead to demonstrate your power to control outcomes.’”
Madness Takes Hold
Jasper pointed at a bakery. “I will make the next customer buy a cinnamon roll!” He focused. The door opened. The customer walked in—bought a croissant.
Tim tried to control a dog’s bark from afar. The dog ignored him.
Lila concentrated on making a clock stop. The second hand ticked on, unmoved by her efforts.
“No!” cried Jasper. “We must try harder!”
“Or think smarter,” Elementary Man muttered.
The Breaking Point
The friends refused to accept defeat.
“We just need proof!” Lila shouted.
“Fine,” said Elementary Man, placing the same coin on the table. “Make it float.”
They tried. Their eyes burned. Their fingers twitched. Their minds ached.
The coin sat still.
Silence fell.
Then Jasper collapsed into his chair. “Maybe… maybe we aren’t in control after all.”
Elementary Man Explains
Elementary Man smiled. “Ah, realization dawns! You are victims of the Illusion of Control. Your minds tricked you. You saw meaning in chance. You believed thoughts could bend reality.”
“But,” Tim argued, “some people really influence things, right?”
“Influence, yes. Control, no.” Elementary Man tapped his teacup. “One can train, prepare, adapt and do things that influence several but not all outcomes… but never dictate the world’s every turn. Even the best detective cannot will tea to be sweeter. He must add sugar.”
They sat, speechless.
The Final Twist
A gust of wind rolled through the café. The friends shivered, glancing at the untouched coin on the table.
“You know,” said Jasper, “that was brainy, man.”
Elementary Man stood, adjusting his coat. “Nay, my friends. That’s Elementary Man!”
Moral of the Short Story
The Illusion of Control can lead us into frustration and folly. Believing we have power over chance creates false confidence—and eventual disappointment. Instead of trying to command the universe, we must master ourselves, our skills, and our choices. True wisdom lies in knowing the difference between what we can influence and what we must accept.
If you enjoyed this short story, then you will like our short story collection.
