In a curious little nook of the world, where the sunbeams danced and the shadows played, a question flitted through the air like a butterfly: “Is that a paper plane? Is that a pencil? Is it an eraser, perhaps?” But lo! A voice rang out, clear and bright, “Nay, my friends. That’s Elementary Man!”

House of Luxury

In the heart of the city, where the streets smelled of roasted chestnuts and expensive perfume, a luxury store stood proudly under golden lights: Maison Merveille. It was a place of velvet carpets, whispered transactions, and price tags that could cause heart palpitations.

Tonight, the store had lured in a few unsuspecting shoppers—among them, Nathan, an ambitious young lawyer, and Clara, a wealthy  woman who was celebrating her celebration from a toxic partner. They emerged from the store beaming, clutching crisp bags with golden handles.

“I finally got the Celestique Timepiece!” Nathan declared. “It was the smartest buy in the store—only $4,500!”

From the shadows of a nearby café, a voice cut through the evening air.

“Was it? Or did they make you think so?”

The speaker stepped into the light: ElementaryMan, the whimsical detective known for uncovering the hidden logic behind life’s little deceptions. Dressed in his signature three-piece suit, he adjusted his monocle and gave Nathan an amused look.

“Walk me through your purchase,” ElementaryMan said, twirling his cane. “You saw this watch and thought it was a bargain?”

Nathan nodded. “Well, there was a $12,000 watch—ridiculous, obviously. And another one for $4,800, but it was bulkier and honestly kind of ugly. So I went with the smart option—the $4,500 one.”

ElementaryMan chuckled. “Ah. The Decoy Effect strikes again.”

The Trickery Revealed

Clara frowned. “Decoy… Effect?”

ElementaryMan gestured dramatically at the storefront. “The store didn’t offer you three choices. They designed your choice. The $12,000 watch? A price anchor to make the others seem reasonable. The $4,800 watch? That was never meant to sell—it existed to make the $4,500 watch look like an absolute steal.”

Nathan blinked. “Wait. They wanted me to buy this one?”

“Exactly,” ElementaryMan confirmed. “If they had only shown you the $4,500 watch, you might have hesitated. But by placing a slightly worse $4,800 option next to it, they manipulated your brain into thinking you’d outsmarted them.”

Clara looked at her own purchase—a $3,200 handbag. “Wait… there was an uglier version for $3,500. And I thought, ‘Wow, mine is so much better for less!’” She gasped. “Oh no. Did I fall for it too?”

ElementaryMan nodded solemnly. “I’m afraid so.”

Escaping the Trap

Nathan groaned. “So… how do we avoid this in the future?”

ElementaryMan tipped his hat. “Simple. Whenever you see a ‘deal’ in a luxury store, look at what’s around it. If there’s an oddly overpriced or slightly worse option next to it, ask yourself: Is this a smart purchase… or a well-placed illusion?”

Clara held up her shopping bag. “So what now? Return them?”

ElementaryMan shrugged. “That depends. If you love what you bought, keep it. But if you only bought it because you thought you were being clever… well, Maison Merveille still has an open return policy.”

The golden doors of the store gleamed under the city lights. A sales clerk inside raised an eyebrow, sensing hesitation in their latest victims—ahem, customers.

Would they return their purchases? Or would they walk away, tricked but wiser?

One thing was certain—Maison Merveille wasn’t the only one playing the game.

Moral of the Short Story: Beware of tricks like the decoy effect that are using to manipulate one in choosing goods that one would have not purchased otherwise.

If you enjoyed this short story, you will also like our short story collection.